People v. . McKane
People v. . McKane, 98 Sickels 455 (1894)
Winning Party
People
Key Issue
Violation of election law regarding the registry of voters (Laws of 1892, chap. 680).
Case Type
CRIMINAL
Facts
•
The defendant was indicted along with three election inspectors for violating election laws related to voter registration.
•
The town's population was 8,343, while the registry lists contained 6,580 names, and the total vote reported was 3,676.
•
The defendant held numerous positions of power in the town.
•
The registry lists were fraudulent.
•
The registry lists were fraudulent, containing a large number of names that did not represent legal voters.
•
There was evidence of a criminal conspiracy or general scheme to cast a large fraudulent vote at the election.
•
The defendant procured the election inspectors to conceal the registry lists.
•
The defendant made an affidavit stating that the lists contained no fraudulent names, despite evidence to the contrary.
•
The charge against the defendant was that he procured the inspectors to conceal the lists.
•
The defendant was tried separately and convicted, and the judgment was affirmed by the Supreme Court.
•
Individuals attempting to access the lists were driven from the hall, beaten, and arrested.
•
The defendant, as chief of police and chairman of the town board, controlled the town hall and the police force.
•
Section 29 of the Penal Code defines a principal as one who aids or abets in the commission of a crime or procures another to commit a crime.
•
The defendant controlled both the Republican and Democratic organizations in the town.
•
Inspectors in all six districts concealed the registry lists from the public.
•
The town of Gravesend was divided into six election districts converging at the town hall, facilitating control over elections.
•
A candidate for justice, Mr. Gaynor, sought court orders to compel access to the lists, but his efforts were resisted.
•
The defendant had a motive to retain his power and influence.
•
The defendant was not an election inspector.
•
The defendant held numerous positions of power in the town, including supervisor and superintendent of the Sabbath school.
•
The charge against the inspectors was that they willfully neglected and refused to make certified copies of the voter lists accessible to the public.
•
The defendant obstructed access to the registry lists.
Explore this Case with AI
Ask about this case, find precedent, analyze legal issues, or draft provisions. Powered by all precedential U.S. cases (10M+)
No credit card required
Key Holdings
•
Yes, the evidence, including the defendant's control over the town, his efforts to obstruct access to the lists, and the fraudulent nature of the lists, was sufficient for the jury to find that the defendant aided, abetted, counseled, and advised the inspectors.
•
Yes, a person who induces or procures election inspectors to commit an offense can be held liable as a principal under Section 29 of the Penal Code, even if they are not an election officer themselves.
Citations
People v. . McKane, 98 Sickels 455, 1894 N.Y. LEXIS 973, 62 St. Rep. 829, 143 N.Y. 455, 38 N.E. 950, 62 N.Y. St. Rep. 829, 9 N.Y. Crim. 377 (1894)
Legal Reasoning
The court reasoned that the defendant, though not an election officer, could be held liable for procuring the inspectors to violate the election law under Penal Code § 29. The court also found that the evidence presented, including the defendant's control over the town, his obstruction of access to the lists, and the fraudulent nature of the lists, was sufficient for the jury to find that the defendant aided, abetted, counseled, and advised the inspectors in their misconduct. The court addressed various exceptions raised by the defendant, finding them to be without merit or harmless error.
Outcome
The judgment of the Supreme Court affirming the defendant's conviction was affirmed.
Want to Learn More About StrongSuit?
StrongSuit has advanced legal AI tools for deep insights & comprehensive analysis
No credit card required
Copyright 2026 StrongSuit AI, Inc. | All Rights Reserved